by Jo Huffhines/Trekking Tours and Travel
As a luxury travel advisor who specializes in curating unforgettable Italian getaways, I am often asked, "Where is the absolute best place to stay?" The truth is, Italy is embarrassed by riches when it comes to hospitality. However, there are certain properties that stand head and shoulders above the rest—places that aren't just hotels, but destinations in themselves.
Based on my professional experience and the glowing feedback I receive from my clients, I have rewritten and curated this guide to the 11 Most Amazing Hotels in Italy. These are the properties where I send travelers who want the very best in service, history, and pure Italian magic.
1. Le Sirenuse | Positano, Amalfi Coast
The Vibe: Elegant, Intimate, Iconic. This isn't just a hotel; it’s an institution. Originally an 18th-century villa belonging to the aristocratic Sersale family, Le Sirenuse retains the feeling of a private home—albeit one with Michelin-starred dining and a pool terrace that offers the most photographed view in the world. It is the gold standard for Amalfi Coast luxury.
Why I Recommend It: The attention to detail is unmatched, from the curated antiques to the "Eau d'Italie" bath products.
💬 From My Clients: "It was the highlight of our honeymoon. We mentioned it was our anniversary, and the staff surprised us with a bottle of vintage prosecco and a handwritten note from the owner. We felt like royalty." — Jessica & Mark, New York
"Worth every penny for the breakfast view alone. Sitting there with a cappuccino watching the fog lift off the cliffs is a memory I'll keep forever." — The Thompson Family
2. The Gritti Palace, a Luxury Collection Hotel | Venice
The Vibe: Opulent, Historic, Venetian Splendor. If you want to feel like Venetian royalty, this is where you stay. Located right on the Grand Canal, The Gritti Palace is a living museum of heavy damask fabrics, Murano glass chandeliers, and priceless oil paintings. It faces the stunning Santa Maria della Salute basilica, offering one of the most romantic views in the city.
Why I Recommend It: The concierge team here is legendary—they can unlock doors in Venice that remain closed to everyone else.
💬 From My Clients: "The concierge, Ivan, worked a miracle and got us a private tour of St. Mark’s Basilica after hours. It was just us and the mosaics. I still get chills thinking about it." — Sarah L.
"There is no better location. We sat on the Riva Lounge terrace for hours just watching the gondolas go by. Absolute perfection." — David R.
3. Belmond Hotel Splendido | Portofino, Italian Riviera
The Vibe: Glamorous, Timeless, Dolce Vita. Perched high above the glittering bay of Portofino, this former 16th-century monastery has hosted everyone from Winston Churchill to Elizabeth Taylor. It captures the essence of the Italian Riviera: sun-drenched gardens, salt-water pools, and a level of service that anticipates your needs before you do.
Why I Recommend It: The "Chuflay" restaurant in the piazzetta is iconic, but dining poolside at the Splendido is a bucket-list experience.
💬 From My Clients: "I’ve stayed in luxury hotels all over the world, but the service at the Splendido is on another level. They knew how I took my coffee by the second morning. It’s expensive, but the exclusivity is unmatched." — Elena G.
4. Grand Hotel Tremezzo | Lake Como
The Vibe: Grand Dame, Art Nouveau, Floating Pool. Standing guard over Lake Como since 1910, this palace is famous for its floating pool that sits directly on the lake. With its bright orange awnings and lush private park, it balances old-world grandeur with a fun, vibrant energy. The views across to Bellagio are simply breathtaking.
Why I Recommend It: The T Spa is world-class, and the private boat tours they organize are the best way to see the lake.
💬 From My Clients: "The floating pool is just as cool as it looks on Instagram! We loved the candy station in the lobby—such a fun, whimsical touch for a luxury hotel. It kept the vibe from feeling too stuffy." — Tom & David
5. Caesar Augustus Hotel | Anacapri, Capri
The Vibe: Secluded, Panoramic, Cliffside. While many flock to the busy Piazzetta, the true luxury on Capri is found high above in Anacapri. This former royal residence hangs 1,000 feet above the sea, offering what I consider the best view in the entire Mediterranean: the Bay of Naples and Mount Vesuvius framed by classical statues.
Why I Recommend It: It feels miles away from the day-tripper crowds. The sunset here is a spiritual experience.
💬 From My Clients: "The view from our balcony literally brought tears to my eyes. It is the most romantic place we have ever stayed. We canceled our dinner reservations in town just to stay on the terrace." — Emily & James
6. Hotel Hassler Roma | Rome
The Vibe: Legendary, Central, Unbeatable Views. Location is everything in Rome, and the Hassler sits at the very top of the Spanish Steps. It is the residence of choice for visiting dignitaries and celebrities who want the Eternal City at their feet. The style is classic and refined, a quiet sanctuary above the bustle.
Why I Recommend It: Imàgo, the Michelin-starred rooftop restaurant, offers a panoramic view of Rome’s domes that you will never forget.
💬 From My Clients: "Walking out of the hotel and being right at the top of the Spanish Steps made us feel like VIPs. The noise of the city fades away as soon as you step into the lobby." — Michael B.
7. Castello di Casole, A Belmond Hotel | Tuscany
The Vibe: Rustic-Luxe, Expansive, Authentic. For clients seeking the Tuscan dream, this is it. A restored 10th-century castle on a massive estate dotted with olive groves and vineyards. It perfectly blends the ancient stone architecture with modern Italian design. It’s incredible for foodies and wine lovers.
Why I Recommend It: The stargazing here is phenomenal due to the lack of light pollution. It’s a true escape.
💬 From My Clients: "We did the truffle hunting excursion organized by the hotel and it was the highlight of our Italy trip. The estate is magical—it felt like we were the only people in Tuscany." — The Chen Family
8. Grand Hotel Timeo, A Belmond Hotel | Taormina, Sicily
The Vibe: Literary, Dramatic, Sicilian Soul. Located literally next door to the ancient Greek Theatre, the Timeo offers front-row seats to history and views of Mount Etna spewing smoke in the distance. It has a literary history (D.H. Lawrence stayed here) and a terraced garden that smells of citrus and jasmine.
Why I Recommend It: Access to the private beach club at its sister property, Villa Sant'Andrea, gives you the best of both worlds: hills and sea.
💬 From My Clients: "Sipping an Aperol Spritz on the Literary Terrace watching the sunset over Etna... unforgettable. It really captures the soul of Sicily." — Grazia & Paolo
9. Grotta Palazzese | Polignano a Mare, Puglia
The Vibe: Unique, Dramatic, Instagram-Famous. You’ve likely seen this on Pinterest. The hotel is built into the cliffs, but the star attraction is the restaurant located inside a limestone cave overlooking the crashing Adriatic waves. It is one of the most unique dining settings on the planet.
Why I Recommend It: It’s a bucket-list experience. While the rooms are simpler than others on this list, the location is unbeatable for romance.
💬 From My Clients: "Dinner in the cave was surreal. Hearing the waves crash below us while we ate was a once-in-a-lifetime experience. Definitely book a table for sunset!" — Jennifer S.
10. Grand Hotel Minerva | Florence
The Vibe: Urban, Chic, Rooftop Oasis. Florence can be hot and crowded, which is why the Minerva’s rooftop pool (one of the few in the city center) is a game-changer. Located on Piazza Santa Maria Novella, it’s steps from the train station and the Duomo, making it incredibly convenient.
Why I Recommend It: It’s perfect for families or travelers who want to be in the thick of the action but need a pool to cool off in the afternoon.
💬 From My Clients: "The rooftop bar is the place to be. After walking around the Uffizi all day, diving into that pool with a view of the Duomo was a lifesaver." — Alex R.
11. Belmond Hotel Caruso | Ravello, Amalfi Coast
The Vibe: Heavenly, Floating, Masterpiece. Suspended between the sky and the sea, the Caruso is often voted one of the best hotels in the world. The infinity pool here is an architectural marvel that seems to drop off into the clouds. The renovated 11th-century palace features frescoed ceilings and rose gardens that invite pure relaxation.
Why I Recommend It: Ravello is quieter and more artistic than Positano. This is where you go to find peace and unparalleled beauty.
💬 From My Clients: "I have traveled all over the world, and the service at the Caruso is the best I have ever experienced. They treated us like family, not just guests." — Robert T.
JOIN OUR WEEKLY LUXURY TRAVEL NEWSLETTER
GAIN ACCESS TO CURATED TRAVEL OPPORTUNITIES NOT AVAILABLE TO THE GENERAL PUBLIC.
EACH WEEK YOU WILL RECEIVE:
Transform your travel experience with insights from our network of luxury travel specialist who understand that exceptional journeys require exceptional planning. Subscribe now to elevate your next adventure.